Joint Statement on Assisted Dying Bills

Riana Rae Brown • May 12, 2025

Joint Statement on Assisted Dying Bills from the Daughters of Charity of St Vincent de Paul and Daughters of Charity Services

The coming week sees two key dates for significant legislation in both Scotland and England.

On 13 May, MSPs in Holyrood will vote on the Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill, which is currently at Stage 1.

Meanwhile, on 16 May, MPs in the House of Commons will vote on the Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults Bill, as it has its third reading in the House.

Both the Daughters of Charity of St Vincent de Paul and Daughters of Charity Services express our firm opposition to both of these Bills.

We believe in the innate dignity of every human person, and that our duty of care to those in need extends throughout their life. We believe that when people are at their most vulnerable, we as a society have an obligation to treat them with loving, dignified care, rather than to create a system which may put pressure on vulnerable people to seek to prematurely end their lives.

Building on our Searching for Consensus report on the state of social care in England last year, we continue to call for greater investment in the care sector. We believe that greater investment in holistic and dignified palliative care would be a much more appropriate response to the suffering of people with a terminal illness than the proposed legislation.

We believe that the proposed legislation risks opening the door to a system in which vulnerable people could be encouraged to end their own lives; to be designated as a burden rather than as a suffering person in need of loving accompaniment. From the experience of countries where such legislation has already been implemented, we have seen the safeguards discussed around this legislation gradually weakened, and we can expect to see a similar pattern take place here if this legislation is passed.

If we accept the innate dignity of every human life, it is clear that our responsibility must be to extend our love, compassion and support to ease the suffering of those at their most vulnerable, and to accompany them on this journey, rather than encouraging people to choose to die. As such, we must oppose these Bills.

Contact Your Representative

We would encourage all of our supporters, and all those who share our values, to write to their local MP, and where appropriate their local MSP, expressing their concern over the issues raised in these Bills, and their opposition to them.

If you have not contacted your representative before, you can find their contact details for Westminster here:

And for Holyrood, here:

Further Information

The Catholic Bishops Conference of England and Wales have produced useful guidance on this issue, which can be found at:

The Bishops Conference of Scotland has published its response to the consultation on the Bill, which can be found at:

Further information on the work of our organisations can be found at:

By Riana Brown October 15, 2025
Dear Chancellor, We are Daughters of Charity Services, a family of charities across Great Britain dedicated to improving the lives of people experiencing the effects of poverty, social exclusion and injustice. As we approach the Autumn Budget, we are calling for additional investment in a number of key areas which we believe would improve the lives and the opportunities of the people our charities serve, and similar communities across the country. In doing so, we draw both on research into these areas at a national level, and on the direct experience of those we are called to serve. In calling for this investment, we echo the concerns of many like-minded charitable organisations, emphasising that the burden of any additional investment should fall on those who are most able to shoulder this, rather than increasing the challenges already faced by so many hard-working individuals and families across our nation.  Child Poverty With an estimated 4.5 million children now living below the poverty line, the following measures are essential to reversing the rise in child poverty and to protect families from further hardship. End the Two-Child Cap We join charities across the country in calling for this policy to be abolished. Almost 1.7 million children are impacted by the two-child cap, and research by Child Poverty Action Group found removing the cap would lift around 350,000 children out of hardship immediately. Importantly, 59% of families affected by this policy have at least one parent in work, demonstrating it is keeping working families in poverty. We also echo other Catholic charities, such as the Bishop’s Conference, who argue that “the existence of the two-cap policy implies that society owes less financial security to third, fourth or younger children.” As their quotation from Pope Francis says, large families are “an investment to guarantee the futures of our societies.” Introduce a ‘Protected Minimum Floor’ We support the Joseph Rowntree Foundation’s call to introduce a ‘protected minimum floor’, whereby the total amount that can be taken from a household’s Universal Credit is limited. This will ensure that no household falls below a basic standard of living due to debt repayments or the benefit cap, and will prevent families who are already struggling being pushed further into crisis. Universal Free School Meals Earlier this year, the government extended Free School Meals to all children from families who receive Universal Credit. This was a welcome move that increased eligibility to over half a million previously ineligible children. However, we urge the government to go further. A recent report by Aberlour Children’s Charity found that 23.1% of children who do not receive free school meals live in families that are in debt. Many schools report having to dip into already limited school funds to provide food for children whose families cannot afford to provide a pack lunch. Extending Free School Meals to all primary age children would ensure that every child is treated with dignity and has a nutritious meal at school. Increase funding to tackle homelessness According to Shelter, 169,050 children were recorded to be living in temporary accommodation in England at the end of March 2025. This represents a 12% increase in just one year, reflecting the severe shortage of affordable homes and the growing pressure on local authorities. There are proven long-term implications on children living in unsuitable temporary accommodation, including poor educational outcomes, an increased chance of developing mental health issues, and social isolation. Investment in homelessness prevention and supported housing is critical. Social Care The recently announced £500 million investment to support the first ever Fair Pay Agreement was very welcome and will make a meaningful difference to the social care sector at a time of great difficulty. However, this alone is not enough. Funding has consistently failed to keep pace with rising demand, and significantly more investment is required to fix major issues in the sector. In our 2024 report, Searching for Consensus , we argued that the government commit to funding the sector by an extra £3.4bn by 2028/29, as proposed by the Health Foundation. This Budget must address the growing gap between current funding and necessary funding, to future-proof the sector and ensure people in need of high-quality care have access to it. Additionally, funding should be backed with a clear plan for how it will support both care users and workers, including fair pay, improved training and career progression pathways. Asylum System In our recent report, Designed into the System , we detailed the extent to which poverty is inflicted on people seeking asylum in the UK. No individual should be forced to live in overcrowded, unsanitary or unsafe accommodation, yet thousands of vulnerable people – including pregnant women and children – are subject to “gruelling” and “dehumanising” living conditions, and cannot access essentials such as women’s sanitary products and infant formula. We urge the Chancellor to use this Budget to change asylum policy, ensuring that people who have fled persecution are not forced to endure poverty unnecessarily. We also call for the government to grant people seeking asylum the right to work after six months in roles on the Shortage Occupation List. This would support integration, give people seeking asylum the opportunity to partake in our economy, improve their physical and mental health, and reduce the risk of destitution. It would also help address urgent labour shortages in sectors such as care and hospitality. This policy change could raise an additional £97.8 million in tax revenue for the government, which would be useful at a time when the government is looking for ways to increase tax revenue. Disability Benefits As our final recommendation, we ask the government to reconsider its proposed cuts to disability benefits and PIP, which will push hundreds of thousands of people living with a disability, as well as their dependent children, further into poverty. These cuts will not support the people who really need it, but rather hinder their ability to work. Furthermore, it is crucial that people with lived experience, and organisations representing them, are consulted before any future reforms to disability benefits, to ensure changes genuinely support independent living and fair access to employment. Conclusion We hope the Chancellor will consider our recommendations and use this opportunity to deliver a Budget that places compassion, justice and inclusion at its core. By investing in these key areas, the Government can ensure that the most vulnerable individuals are protected, supported, and able to fully participate in society.
By Riana Brown September 30, 2025
Please click to download our latest issue of the newsletter.
A man with a suitcase and child in a yellow jacket walk down a sidewalk, holding hands.
August 5, 2025
New report exposes how the UK asylum system fuels poverty, hunger & homelessness. Calls for urgent reform to restore dignity & justice for seekers.
A wheelchair is parked in a hallway of a hospital.
July 25, 2025
Explore the “Searching for Consensus” report on England’s care crisis. Discover key reforms for recruitment, retention & funding in adult social care.
A group of people are putting their hands together on a wooden table.
July 25, 2025
Discover how six Vincentian charities lifted 1,333 families, invested £1.99 m in frontline care and advanced justice across Great Britain in 2023-24.
Woman in a suit, holding a red briefcase, stands outside a building with a dark façade.
By Riana Rae Brown June 12, 2025
Welcomes school meal expansion, housing & social care funding; urges universal FSM, end two-child limit, humane asylum with right to work and safe housing.
By Riana Rae Brown June 10, 2025
Ahead of the 11 June spending review, DCS urges £3.4bn for social care, fair pay & training, free school meals for primary pupils, and scrapping two-child limit.
Woman in orange blazer writes in a notebook while looking at papers at a desk.
By Riana Rae Brown May 26, 2025
Apply by 30 June 2025: Daughters of Charity Services seeks a Trustee with legal expertise. Join our Vincentian-values board across Britain.
By Riana Rae Brown April 22, 2025
Daughters of Charity Services honor the life and legacy of Pope Francis, celebrating his dedication to the poor, compassion, and call to service.
An older Black man in a tan sweater working on a laptop at an outdoor cafe.
By Chae Kim January 27, 2025
Read the December 2024 Rosalie Rendu Newsletter from Daughters of Charity Province — issue 15 featuring community stories, updates, and inspiration.
Show More